Sentencing Advocacy Competition 2026
The 2026 Annual High Court Sentencing Competition final concluded with Spencer Withers named the winner and Abbey Smith the runner-up.
Left to Right: Spencer Withers, Dr Simon Foote KC, Justice Blanchard and Abbey Smith.
Justice Blanchard presided over the evening and questioned the finalists throughout their 20-minute submissions on the appropriate sentence for a single manslaughter charge. The finalists demonstrated their advocacy skills while presenting their respective cases before the Court.
Dr Simon Foote KC attended the final and spoke about the importance of the sentencing hearing and the skills advocates should develop when appearing as Crown or defence counsel. “Sentencing hearings are perhaps the most challenging and fraught hearings for the defendant, victims, counsel and of course the judge. Counsel have the difficult task of representing the Crown or the defendant in what can be emotionally charged circumstances. They must be courageous in their advocacy for their respective clients but always seek to assist the court. Both the finalists in this competition did a fine job in all these respects.”
Sponsored by Te Tāhū o te Ture | the Ministry of Justice and the New Zealand Bar Association | Ngā Ahorangi Motuhake o Te Ture, the competition offers students from the University of Auckland, Auckland University of Technology, and the University of Waikato the rare opportunity to appear before High Court Judges. Students present sentencing submissions on behalf of the prosecution or defence after fictitious defendants plead guilty.
Reflecting on the experience, winner Spencer Withers said he particularly valued the independence the competition gave participants: “I really enjoyed the whole process of the sentencing competition! It was great having the freedom to independently research and come up with arguments myself. I’m really grateful for the work that went into running the competition and everyone who wrote the problems!”
Left to Right: Spencer Withers, Abbey Smith and Dr Simon Foote KC
Runner-up Abbey Smith similarly described the competition as a valuable learning opportunity: “This was one of my first competition experiences, and I found it both challenging and rewarding. The problem questions were interesting and allowed for engaging arguments in each round. Having the opportunity to compete against some excellent competitors, in front of incredibly knowledgeable and supportive judges was invaluable. Overall, it was a fantastic learning experience, and I hope to participate again next year.”
Congratulations to the winner, runner-up and all who competed. Opportunities like these help foster the skills, confidence, and commitment to excellence that underpin strong advocacy.
Related News
2026 Silks Announced
16 OctoberThe President and Council of the New Zealand Bar Association…
Read moreThe Bar Association Welcomes New President Dr Simon Foote KC
01 OctoberThe New Zealand Bar Association | Ngā Ahorangi Motuhake o te…
Read moreAccess to Justice Winner 2026 Erin Ebborn
04 SeptemberErin Ebborn has been awarded the 2026 Access to Justice Awar…
Read moreRule of Law Keynote | Roddy Dunlop KC
03 SeptemberAddress to the Bar Association of New Zealand: The Independe…
Read more